How to replace a lost Jellycat (even a retired one)

Jellycat makes many similar-looking toys, in several sizes, and retires designs regularly. That's why replacing one takes a little detective work.

1. Pin down the exact toy

  • Name: the cardboard hang tag shows the toy's name. If it's gone, search your photos, gift messages or order emails for it.
  • Size: many Jellycats come in several sizes under the same name. Measure head to foot and compare with the size listed in shop listings.
  • Colour and fabric: the same character is often made in several colours, and fabric can change between production years.
  • The sewn-in label: it usually confirms the brand. Some also carry a date or batch code, which helps tell older versions apart.

2. If it's still sold

Search the name on Jellycat's website or at a toy shop that stocks the brand. Check the size and colour against yours before you order.

3. If it's been retired

Retired Jellycats sell second-hand all the time:

  • eBay, Vinted, Mercari and Facebook Marketplace for "pre-loved" ones.
  • Collector groups, where people trade retired designs.
  • Image search (Google Lens) with a clear photo of yours, to catch listings that use a different name.

Popular retired designs can cost more than they did new, so set a search alert and compare a few listings.

4. Check before you buy

Ask the seller for a photo of the sewn-in label and one next to a ruler. Compare the face, fabric and colour with yours. Look-alike toys from other makers are common.

Let us search for you

Send us a photo of your Jellycat, even an old one, and we'll search resale sites and shops worldwide for the exact same one. Free to search; you only pay if we find it. Detective Teddy isn't affiliated with Jellycat.

Want us to look for you?
Send one photo. We search resale sites and shops worldwide. Free to search, and you only pay if we find it.
Send a photo

Last updated November 18, 2026.

From $9.
Only if we find it.
No match, no charge — plus a free alert if one turns up later.
See prices