Should you buy a spare comfort toy?

If your child has one toy they can't sleep without, a spare is the cheapest insurance you'll ever buy.

Why keep a spare

  • Toys get lost: on trips, at nursery, in the washing machine.
  • Toys wear out: a well-loved toy can be held together by stitches within a few years.
  • Toys get retired: brands discontinue designs all the time, and a toy that's easy to buy today can be hard to find in two years.

Rotate them, so they stay "the same"

Children notice a brand-new spare: it's fluffier, stiffer and smells different. Swap the two every week or two, and wash them on the same schedule, so they age together. When one goes missing, the other is a real replacement, not a stranger.

Buy it while you can

If the toy is still sold, buy the spare now: same name, same size, same colour. Check the sewn-in label matches, because brands sometimes change fabrics between production runs.

Already discontinued?

Then a second-hand one is your best option. Our guides cover finding a discontinued stuffed animal and buying a second-hand one safely. Or send us a photo, and we'll search resale sites and shops worldwide for the exact same toy. You only pay if we find it.

Want us to look for you?
Send one photo. We search resale sites and shops worldwide. Free to search, and you only pay if we find it.
Send a photo

Last updated November 18, 2026.

From $9.
Only if we find it.
No match, no charge — plus a free alert if one turns up later.
See prices